Jan 15, 2013 - Communication    2 Comments

Romeo and Juliet.

Romeo and Juliet – one of Shakespeare’s greatest works – is constantly filled with references to fate.
In this essay I will be talking about key elements that suggest fate in the play. In Romeo and Juliet there are many references to their own death. This will be my first subject. My second topic will be the way in which Romeo loses his faith. For the third paragraph there will be a complicated paradox.

” I fear, too early, for my mind misgives
Some consequence yet hanging in the stars
Shall bitterly begin his fearful date
With this night’s revels, and expire the term
Of a despised life clos’d in my breast
By some vile forfeit of untimely death.
But He that hath the steerage of my course
Direct my sail! On, lusty gentlemen!”

In this quote Romeo is saying to the audience that if he enters this party, the events that will follow will cause his passing (this is the party where he will meet Juliet and set off the events that will lead to his death.) This is the first main point in the play where Romeo talks about his death. What Romeo is saying is even though he knows going to this party will eventually course his death, he is willing to let God make the decisions for him.
This tells the reader two things: one that Romeo is obviously very religious, and two, that Romeo is clearly predicting his death. The image Shakespeare uses to show this is that God is the captain and Romeo is the ship.

In the times of Shakespeare’s plays religion was as important as politics. Shakespeare uses this to his advantage. Romeo losing his faith could be argued to be the real tragedy. The quote above implies that Romeo is willing to put his life in danger if God wants him to.
“I defy you stars”
This is very important for Romeo as it means he is so in love with Juliet that he is willing to forget God. This gives more reason for Romeo to kill himself. In the film the death of Tybalt comes in front of a statue of Jesus. Killing, in the eyes of Christians, is the second worst sin that you can commit. This then shows that he is gradually losing his faith. First he slays Tybalt in front of Jesus, then he commits suicide in a Church, the home os God.

Suicide, in those days, was considered the worst sin of all as it took the choice about whether a person lives or dies away from God. Many times in the play, God controls events that lead to Romeo’s suicide. This implies that Romeo it is not Romeo’s fault that he committed suicide. The best example of this is when Frier John is stopped from delivering the message because of a disease which causes the area that he is staying in to be quarranteened. If that message, telling Romeo that although Juliet looked dead, she was still loving, had reached Romeo, he would not have committed suicide. Maybe what is happening here is that Romeo’s suicide has been controlled by God but for a different reason than we may first presume. After Romeo and Juliet’s bodies are discovered, the Capulets and the Montegues decide to end their argument and draw up a truce. God has used these two young people’s suicides to stop the ongoing disagreement which could have led to war and the deaths of many more people.

As we have seen, Shakespeare uses fate in many ways. However, in my opinion, the most important way in which fate is used is to direct the plot. Fate makes people do things and events happen in a story which do not need to be explained in other ways. It is like an unseen force directing characters. In those times fate was God.

2 Comments

  • Arthur,

    This piece is shaping up well – and already demonstrates what a subtle understanding you have of the mechanisms of fate that Shakespeare includes in his play.

    Just to take your idea about Romeo defying God by killing himself (and this is indeed a clever interpretation of the events in relation to God and fate) how about this for a paradox:

    Shakespeare suggests that God is determining Romeo’s path, and he even has Romeo agree to surrender to his wishes. We are told by the chorus in the prologue that the two are going to kill themselves and by doing so bring about the reconciliation of their families. but if that is the case and if killing yourself is one of the few things humans can do to defy God, then how can Romeo killing himself be the continuation of God’s will? surely this is Romeo asserting his will over that of God?

    This makes my mind hurt – and being a paradox, it cannot be resolved.

    In relation to your writing, I have some advice about the style:

    1) Avoid using the personal pronoun “I” and being too conversational in your formal essay writing. It is better that you simply state your ideas with clarity than try to ‘discuss’ them with your reader. Here is an example:

    It is something that we did not talk about in class but I think is quite important

    This would be better expressed as: “A possible interpretation of Romeo’s actions is..”

    The reason I’m asking for you to do this with your writing is that it will give it much greater authority. This comment is written in an informal style because it’s addressed directly to you. An essay, by comparison, should be addressed to a wider audience of the public and is your way to express an idea that is supported by as many facts as possible.

    Have a look at this essay by Kamrul, a year 10 student – it is written in a very effective formal style and he communicates some very complex ideas with such precision that it almost seems as if the ideas are obvious:

    http://the_great_one.student.edutronic.net/2012/12/16/controlled-assessment-spoken-language-study/

    It’s great to be working with you on writing without having to worry so much about spelling!!

    Righto!

    Mr Waugh

    • thanks sir.

Got anything to say? Go ahead and leave a comment!

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox

Join other followers: